On Prime Minister Carney’s Comments Regarding Tariffs in Canada–U.S. Trade Negotiations

The Modern Commons Party of Canada is deeply concerned by Prime Minister Mark Carney’s recent statement acknowledging that tariffs are “almost certain” in any future trade deal with the United States. This revelation, following closely on the heels of Canada’s withdrawal of the Digital Services Tax (DST), signals a troubling shift in Canada’s approach to defending its economic sovereignty.

“We’ve already made major concessions in good faith,” said Jack Henry, Leader of the Modern Commons Party. “But if the result is still tariffs on Canadian goods, then what exactly did we gain? Canadians deserve a government that knows how to negotiate from strength, not from fear.”

The removal of the DST—a targeted measure designed to ensure large foreign tech companies pay their fair share—was framed as a necessary compromise to keep trade negotiations alive and avoid punitive tariffs. But now, just days later, the Prime Minister is preparing the public for tariffs anyway. This pattern raises a serious question: what was the point of conceding early, if it did nothing to protect Canadian workers, businesses, and exporters?

The Modern Commons Party believes that Canada’s trade policy must be guided by three principles:

1. Defend Canada’s Interests

We do not accept the inevitability of unfair tariffs. Strong, independent nations do not enter negotiations assuming they will lose. Instead of trying to manage damage, our government should be working to prevent it—through assertive diplomacy, clear red lines, and unwavering support for key industries.

“Tariffs are not just numbers on paper—they’re real consequences for farms, factories, and families,” Henry said. “We can’t afford to let another generation of Canadian workers pay the price for political caution in Ottawa.”

2. Diversify Trade

Modern Commons has long advocated for diversifying Canada’s international trade partnerships. While the United States will always be an important economic partner, we must reduce our dependence by opening new opportunities in Europe, Asia, and Latin America.

This approach builds resilience and ensures that Canada’s economy is never held hostage by a single trading relationship.

3. Stand Up for Fair Taxation

Backing away from the Digital Services Tax was a mistake. The tax was never about punishing innovation—it was about fairness. Canadian businesses are required to contribute to our public services; multinational tech giants profiting off our data and digital economy should be no different.

“Canadians aren’t afraid of global competition,” said Henry. “But we expect a fair fight—and a government that’s in our corner when the rules aren’t applied equally.”

Our Call to Action

The Modern Commons Party is calling on the federal government to:

• Publicly clarify what kinds of tariffs are on the table and what sectors are most at risk

• Set a firm timeline for progress in trade talks—and explain what steps will be taken if that progress stalls

• Reaffirm Canada’s right to introduce fair digital taxation, especially if the international framework continues to face delays

• Launch a resilience strategy to support Canadian industries that may be impacted by tariffs or prolonged trade uncertainty

This moment demands leadership rooted in principle, not panic. Canadians want a government that protects our economic future with courage and clarity—not one that prepares us for losses before the talks even begin.

“We need to remember: a fair deal isn’t one the U.S. tells us to take. It’s one that works for Canada too,” Henry concluded.“Modern Commons is ready to fight for that deal—and for a more independent, more resilient Canadian economy.”